Telling your family that you're in an open relationship is one of the hardest steps in this process. At least it was for me.
And "coming out" has traditionally been a term reserved for kids telling their parents they are queer. This is who I am, Mom.
Polyamory is different. Some people identify as polyamorous, and loving multiple people feels like a core part of who they are. Maybe that's easier, but I wouldn't know.
For me, being open was a choice. A choice to live a more authentic version of myself (yes, I am bisexual). And telling your parents you've chosen something they don't agree with, support, or understand is a different kind of hard.
I share the full story of coming out to my parents below.
Telling your parents something you're worried they don't want to hear is always hard, no matter the reason. In many ways, you're asking people who love you to rethink something they've always believed.
There's no perfect time and no perfect script. But there are things that can make it easier.
This is my number one recommendation.
It's one thing to get questions from strangers online or people at a dinner party. It's something else entirely to answer questions from people who love you deeply and feel responsible for your well-being.
The stakes feel higher because they are.
They're not just asking out of curiosity. They're asking because they want to trust that you're okay. That your relationship is safe. That your kids are safe.
If you're not ready to answer those questions yet, it's okay to wait.
A good signal you're ready is when you feel grounded enough in your relationship that someone else's fear won't immediately shake your certainty. When your parents ask something from a place of fear, you can recognize it as such rather than take it personally.
If I could do it again, I would say less and make more room for questions.
I came out to my monogamous, Midwestern university friends in a long monologue that should have been reserved for a Shakespeare performance (and was probably just as hard to follow).
Not only was I not ready for hard questions, but I tried to compensate with long-winded explanations — answering questions they hadn't even asked yet.
I thought if I could just articulate it well enough, it would all make sense.
It doesn't work like that.
Long explanations can overwhelm people, especially if this is the first time they're hearing about non-monogamy. They don't yet have the framework to process it.
What works better is simple and direct:
This is our relationship
This is why it works for us
This is how we think about it
And then stop.
Let them ask questions. Let them lead.
Most people's first reaction is emotional, not logical. That's true for most big news.
The more confident and comfortable I became in my choice to be ethically non-monogamous, the easier it was to see that.
The fears I've heard, especially from family:
(I've heard multiple variations of religious zingers, but we'll leave it at one.)
For my parents, the biggest concern was the kids. Specifically, that they would be judged or teased, or grow up expecting divorce.
It helped me to recognize that these reactions were coming from fear, not rejection.
When people ask hard or uncomfortable questions, they're usually trying to resolve something that feels unsafe to them.
You don't have to agree with their fears. But understanding where they're coming from makes it easier not to take it personally.
If you can, don't try to do this all at once.
People need time to process. Their first reaction is rarely their final one.
If possible:
The second conversation is often where real understanding starts.
You are allowed to have boundaries.
You can answer the questions that feel fair and grounded, and decline the ones that feel intrusive or irrelevant.
You don't need to explain the details of your sex life. Most people won't ask, but if they do, it's okay to say no.
This is about helping them understand your relationship, not giving them full access to it.
One final thought on timing. I started this by saying to wait until you feel ready to answer hard questions. That's great in theory, but not always possible in practice. There's no perfect moment. You're not waiting for zero anxiety. That moment doesn't exist. But there is a difference between feeling uncertain and trying to convince yourself, and feeling grounded and able to hold someone else's reaction. Tell them when you feel secure enough in your relationship that their response won't define how you see it.
Get honest advice on non-traditional relationships, delivered to your inbox.
Subscribe to Newsletters