This is the conversation that changes everything. Whether you're the one bringing it up or the one hearing it for the first time, there's no way to un-ring this bell. That doesn't mean it has to go badly. In fact, how you approach this conversation often sets the tone for everything that follows. Here's what I've learned — from my own experience and from working with hundreds of couples.
Lead with curiosity, not a request. There's a big difference between "I want to open our relationship" and "I've been thinking about how we relate to each other, and I'd love to explore that with you." Share what you're feeling, not what you want to do. Talk about the emotions driving your curiosity — the desire for growth, for exploration, for deeper honesty — rather than jumping straight to logistics. And give your partner space to react. This might be the first time they're hearing something you've been thinking about for months. They deserve time to process without pressure.
It's okay to feel shocked. It's okay to feel hurt, confused, even angry. Those are all valid reactions to something unexpected. Take time before responding. You don't need to have an answer right now — and you shouldn't try to. Ask questions before making decisions. "What made you start thinking about this?" is a better starting point than "Absolutely not." Understanding where they're coming from doesn't mean you're agreeing to anything. It means you're choosing to stay in the conversation.
Don't issue ultimatums. "Either we open up or I'm leaving" isn't a conversation — it's coercion. Don't bring it up during a fight. This conversation deserves its own space, not the heat of an argument. And don't have someone specific in mind already. If you're asking to open your relationship because there's a particular person you want to date, that's not opening up — that's asking for permission. Your partner will feel the difference, even if you don't say it out loud.
If your partner dismisses your feelings — whether you're the one asking or the one reacting — that's a problem. Healthy relationships make room for difficult emotions, even when the topic is uncomfortable. If the conversation is one-sided, with one person doing all the talking and the other shutting down, slow down and try again later. And if there's pressure to decide immediately — from either side — that's a sign the conversation needs more space, not less.
When Rich first brought it up, I didn't take it well. Not even a little. I've written about what happened next — the confusion, the arguments, the slow process of actually listening to each other. Read the full story here.
Get honest advice on non-traditional relationships, delivered to your inbox.
Subscribe to Newsletters