I remember when Rich first brought up the idea of opening our relationship. We'd only been dating a few months. My initial reaction was shock, then disappointment, then confusion. He said all the right things (many of which I'm about to recommend here) but my first reaction was still hurt. I grew up in a monogamous household with a fairytale idea of meeting my one and only true love. I understood the logic of what he was proposing. Emotionally, it still stung.
That was over 15 years ago. We've been openly committed ever since.
The goal isn't to have it go perfectly. The goal is to have it go honestly, with enough care that you can keep talking after it's over.
This is the conversation that can change everything. So whether you're the one bringing it up or the one hearing it for the first time, how you approach it often sets the tone for everything that follows.
If you want to read the story of what our first conversation was like, I wrote about it here.
There's no wrong answer. But clarity matters.
Before you bring non-monogamy up to your partner, get honest with yourself about why you want to explore it. This might take some time on your own first. It's worth it.
When you start from why, you invite your partner into a real conversation. When you start from what, you hand them a decision to react to.
When you bring it up to your partner, lead with why, not what.
"I want to be in an open relationship" is a solution. And when you communicate a solution before you state the problem, you've already closed the door on other possibilities. Your partner is now reacting to the answer you've decided on, not the question you're both trying to answer together.
These are why statements. They name what's true for you without prescribing the outcome. An open relationship might end up being the answer, but it's one possible answer, not the only one.
You want your partner's genuine "yes" or their genuine "no" — not a "yes" shaped by fear.
A few things to keep in mind.
"I need time to think about this" is a complete sentence.
Maybe you're here because your partner sent you this page. First: your reaction, whatever it is, is valid. Shock, hurt, confusion, anger, curiosity, relief. All of these are normal responses to something unexpected.
None of these mean non-monogamy is off the table forever. But they do usually mean not yet.
Most couples can have a version of this conversation and come out the other side, even if the answer ends up being "no, this isn't for us." But some situations are genuinely not the time to open a relationship. A few signs to take seriously:
Some conversations need a different conversation to come first.
The initial conversation is rarely just one conversation. It's the first in a series that unfolds over weeks, months, sometimes years.
Rich and I didn't resolve anything the evening he first brought it up. We didn't resolve it the next week, either. What we did was keep talking. I look back and estimate it took me two years to feel confident and excited about the relationship style we were building together. Oh, and it happened to be open.
Get honest advice on non-traditional relationships, delivered to your inbox.
Subscribe to Newsletters